Computational & AI Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling

Four leading cofolding models often place ligands well yet get the receptor's functional conformational state wrong, limiting their use for state-selective design

  • Four current AI cofolding models were compared on kinase and Class A GPCR complexes, using structures deposited after every model's training cutoff so the test is genuinely out-of-sample.
  • Ligand poses frequently looked accurate while state-defining features, such as kinase activation-loop and DFG/DYG arrangements or GPCR intracellular loops, were predicted incorrectly.
  • Adding state-annotated templates or filtered alignments helped only in some systems, confidence scores tracked ligand placement but not pocket accuracy, and the one allosteric complex was missed by every model.
Points Based on the abstract

A low ligand RMSD was never proof the pocket is right, and this study shows why that matters for kinase and GPCR work. If your design hypothesis hinges on DFG-out or an inactive-state loop, treat a cofolded pose as a hypothesis, not a structure. Before trusting it, I'd compare against docking into a state-matched experimental structure and check whether the model just recalled the nearest training-set state. The allosteric miss is a single case, so I wouldn't generalize it.