Computational & AI chemRxiv

Deleting a second bound ligand copy can derail redocking, notably for P-glycoprotein

  • Standard redocking removes every copy of a ligand, so structures with two copies in one cavity are docked into a pocket never seen empty.
  • Retrospective tests on deposited P-glycoprotein structures, with the search box fixed on the known pose, compared deleting versus retaining the second copy, plus a carbon-only ghost and a volume-matched box control, and a second docking program.
  • Retaining the copy markedly improved poses, driven mainly by apolar occlusion; across eight other proteins no consistent direction emerged. Authors advise reporting both ways.
Points Based on the abstract

This is a nice reminder that a redocking success rate is partly a property of how we prepared the structure. The ghost-atom and volume-matched controls are the right ones. For P-gp or other multi-copy cavities on your project, run both preparations and treat any benchmark that silently deleted the second copy with some suspicion.