Computational & AI Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation (ACS)

Water-transfer alchemical method estimates RBFE when a bridging water is displaced

  • Extends the Alchemical Transfer Method so a ligand and its bound water are moved together between the binding site and bulk, handling congeneric pairs that differ in substituent and in the number of bridging waters.
  • This sidesteps the sampling problem of kinetically trapped waters that standard relative binding free energy protocols struggle with.
  • Evaluated retrospectively on a protein-ligand set previously used to test water-displacement and water-sampling methods.
  • Predictions were reported as more accurate, reliable and reproducible than standard approaches.
Points Based on the abstract

Retrospective results on a set already used to benchmark water methods tell me little about my own series. The real question is how the water to move is chosen: if it needs prior crystallographic or GCMC insight, the method is only as automatic as that call. Versus coupling/decoupling or GCMC, I'd want cost per edge and agreement when the water count changes.